a review of a review of reviews

Proof that some people, admittedly people who clearly come from a world which is now passed, aren't hip to the new media:

Let me put this bluntly, in language even a busy blogger can understand: Criticism — and its humble cousin, reviewing — is not a democratic activity. It is, or should be, an elite enterprise, ideally undertaken by individuals who bring something to the party beyond their hasty, instinctive opinions of a book (or any other cultural object). It is work that requires disciplined taste, historical and theoretical knowledge and a fairly deep sense of the author's (or filmmaker's or painter's) entire body of work, among other qualities.
From a piece in the LA Times, written by Richard Schickel, "a film critic for Time magazine and a frequent book reviewer for The [LA?] Times."

What the author clearly missed is that the most important thing about reading a review is that the reviewer and you see things the same way. Now, don't get me wrong - there is space for erudite interpretation of works, but that isn't really what we think of when we think of 'review'. Generally, what we want to know is 'should we read X' or 'should we watch Y'. A review by Schickel would clearly not help people much if they think, for example, that the way he looks at the world is total bullocks.

Shelby commented:
Well some of us have a very expensive liberal arts education to pay off, so we need to protect our rightful place, which is of course above the common man as far as reading books go. :P Honestly the way I read reviews on Amazon and other review sites is that I just scan to the bad reviews. After reading those, I decide if the reviews are idiotic ("I give this book 1 star because it arrived with a torn cover" or "My friend has this book and she really hates it DO NOT BUY!!1!!111!") or if they contain worthwhile criticism. This has served me well so far.
on Tue May 22 03:46:55 2007

Erik commented:
My strategy on reviews is somewhat different than Shelby's, at least when it comes to short fan and customer reviews like those at amazon.com. I figure the outliers - both those that are highly negative and highly positive - are by people with a bone to pick or are hardcore fans, and are thus not going to produce an even slightly balanced review. Instead, I look for those in the middle.
on Tue May 22 06:53:59 2007

Add a Comment
Back to the Blog