I’m spending the summer in the UK, cat sitting - it’s a thing we’ve discovered is a nice way to assume someone’s life for a while - it only works if you aren’t absolutely attached to seeing everything everywhere, but would rather do a deep dive in one location or so.
So this first month we’re in Wales, and today we headed to Three Cliffs Bay which is a lovely little beach with cliffs on all three sides (fourth side is the ocean). And as we were walking down, past these absurdly fancy places which were either private residences of the very wealthy or flats to let, owned by the absurdly wealthy, I got to thinking about how we might do a better job of wealth distribution.
Right next door to the wealthy enclave was a caravan (RV) park, which is how we have actually solved the problem - money determines allocation. Although it’s a bit more complicated than that - next to all the fancy houses was one run-down shack that had clearly been there since the glory days of mining in Wales. So we’ve determined that you can either be wealthy, or be the first person to show up and get lucky in your choice of location (or of ancestors, more likely). Neither generational wealth nor instant wealth seem a particularly great way to distribute holiday lets. So I got thinking about how you might allocate places in a non-monetary way - my first thought was a voucher system, where everyone in the nation gets a voucher to use for fancy places to stay. I think it would have to be non-transferrable if you didn’t want it just to become a form of currency.
The thing is, everyone wants the upside of taking risk, but nobody wants the down side. The way to compensate is to take some of the gains from the winners to compensate the losers. This has the effect, positive or negative, of reducing the incentive to take risk, but at the same time it might grow the pool of risk takers who are turned off by the idea of losing everything if they get it wrong.
Now there’s lots of evidence of how vouchers work, and don’t work, around the world, but it’s imperfect - Section 8, for example, is a train wreck, and usually the vouchers are intended to allow access to privately owned resources. However, one element that keeps coming up is the black market - I honestly think a moderately robust system is good enough, since it’s not the end of the world if someone is able to game the system to a certain degree. One thing we often see in these systems is the perfect being the enemy of the good.
Further on that thought, how to deal with people who 'get lucky' or buy early in a location that becomes desirable is particularly tricky. The unearned increment is by definition 'unearned'. How to deal with that without punishing people either by kicking them out of their home or effectively doing so through taxation is a tough nut to crack.
The Economist this week published a defense of the free market against the dangers of Gen-Z socialism (as they call it). But elsewhere they include an important side note - the economy actually has to deliver (though not for everyone, in their view). The lived experience of people doesn’t seem to reflect this, and the issue of the holiday let seems to reflect this admirably.