:: Life Of Dave ::

The Middle East, 2024

I started to type something about how long the current war in the middle east had been going on, before realizing how hard it is to quantify which war we're talking about. I had specifically been thinking about the one that started Saturday, 7 October 2023 with the terrorist attack on Israel. I think it fair to say everything that follows starts there, although it's also certainly fair to say that was just another part of the longer ongoing war.

It's also not totally clear war is the right term. Israel is an apartheid state. There's no getting around that. The history is more complicated than South Africa's, but the outcome is basically the same, maybe worse. But there are so many more players that it's impossible to talk about the whole mess only in terms of Israel and Palestine. And it's the rest of those players that has me posting this today.

Quoting the Washington Post, "Hasan Nasrallah, the head of Hezbollah, was killed in an Israeli strike on Friday... Hezbollah confirmed the death of their commander-in-chief in a statement Saturday afternoon, mourning the man who 'guided them through approximately three decades of leadership characterized by successive victories.'" The post also has a full profile of Nasrallah. I will confess I haven't really kept up on the players on the larger stage - much like school shootings in America, it's too exhausting, and frankly I've been confident in both cases that nothing I say, do, or know will change the situation.

I can't decide, though it appears I'll find out soon enough, if this is a precursor to a full blown war. I also can't decide if Israel is so sure of its military superiority that it just doesn't care. Being outnumbered doesn't matter when you can just mow people down, as Israel has surely shown it is willing to do (regardless of whether the people you mow down are civilians).

I don't see any indication that the US will change strategy - Harris is Biden is Trump is Obama is Bush is Clinton is... when it comes to US foreign policy, for the most part. Certainly if there is a hot war I can't see us stopping arms shipments.

And I don't think there's a universe where even a hot war changes the overall picture - Iran, even if their leadership was removed and replaced with a secular, democratically elected government, isn't going to suddenly think well of Israel. The situation in Palestine guarantees that. They might stop destabilizing the region, which would be nice, but they'd still be a major player with their own interests. Which is something people often seem to forget - I'm thinking for example of the UK during Brexit, and their absurd claims that they would get a better deal out than in. Other countries have different aims, and they don't care about the aims of other players, except where they see advantage or conflict. This has often been the problem with e.g. American intervention in the Middle East - we're simply incapable of recognizing all the competing points of view. Or perhaps unwilling is the better term there.

(one might say this is the problem of American intervention everywhere)

I don't actually have any particular thoughts here, I just thought it was an interesting time to note where we are, so whatever happens I can see what my thoughts were at the time of inflexion. So in six months, or six years, I'll refer back to this, probably with a 'yup - nothing got better'.