deplatforming the right
We've spent the last couple months in France, with Sasha doing research and me doing random stuff. Although we thought we had successfully avoided all the craziness planned for France this year by leaving before the Olympics, the president decided to surprise everyone by calling snap legislative elections while we were here, after the far right dominated European elections.
According to him, it was to provide clarity and to give his government a clear mandate to lead, but given the entire election, from announcement to voting, lasted less than a month, I'm not sure how clarifying anyone found it. Regardless, the left wing parties decided to pull together to provide a stronger option for people to vote for, and in the end it worked, as the new leftist coalition won the majority of seats.
I decided, the day after the election, to buy a newspaper. The national paper had sold out, so I got the local one,
Le Bien Public. Newspapers in France are doing much better than other places, so local papers are still full of quality reporting, and there was perhaps ten to fifteen pages of election coverage. And this is where things got interesting.
In the Dijon area, there were five people elected: three from the left, one from the right, and one from the far-right. Each elected seat was given a half page overview.
The four mainstream candidates each had a reaction quote, some description of what they hoped to accomplish, a description of how their particular area's election had gone (what was important to voters, how attitudes had shifted over time, etc), and a reaction quote from the candidate who did not win, generally conciliatory and wishing the winning candidate well.
And then there was the fifth candidate. In a first for the area, the rural district had elected a member of the
Rassemblement National party. Based on the article and reading between the lines he's an old school right winger, who's been with the RN since the 1970s, when it hadn't avoided being a party of racists and fascists. And now he was an elected official.
So the paper did what we often hear people say we should do with the right wing. It ignored him. Not completely - there was a half page story noting his election, but it consisted basically of the other two candidates saying what a disaster it was that a member of the RN had been elected, and how he had no interest in actually representing the people of the district and hadn't in any way disavowed his awful history. There were no quotes from him.
In some ways this echos what we saw nationwide, as people across France did anything they could to prevent RN candidates from being elected. And it worked.
But.
The RN had the highest number of voters in the country. And this local guy won the election with 28,676 votes (42 more than the other guy, BTW - every vote counts!) And now voters locally and nationally could quite legitimately feel like their voice, their vote, their wishes were being blocked at every turn.
Now don't get me wrong - if I thought that every one of those voters, or even most of those voters, was voting for racism and fascism I'd be very happy to ignore them.
But my understanding is that the reason the RN has done so well, in part, is because it has been going out to the voters and actually talking to them, and addressing their concerns. Not only that, obviously - they've also been whipping up a populist frenzy over whatever they can get people whipped up about, like how foreigners are criminals and job stealers and also lazy benefit stealers at the same time (how does that work?) and etc.
And I am concerned, because this is not at all the first time there has been a national move to block the RN because they did so well in the elections. And yet nobody seems to be drawing the obvious conclusion, that we need to make sure their legitimate concerns are being addressed by one of the mainstream parties, so they don't feel the need to vote for a racist fascist populist party.
So I'm not sure if I agree that completely ignoring this guy except to say 'it's awful' is a good move.
The reason I decided I needed to write this is because I'd never seen, in the English language media, such a complete adherance to the 'we do not give the right wing extremists a platform' idea. It was honestly a real shock to the system, having read the other four reports on the other elected officials, to see such a change in tone. And it made me think, both about my reaction, and about how I would feel if I'd voted for him. I often support left wing candidates who, in the US, are often treated as if they were the same as right wing extremists, and it makes me angry, and it makes me disillusioned, and etc. And that doesn't seem like a good way to make democracy stronger.
So I don't know what the right answer is - maybe Le Bien Public nailed it. But it doesn't feel like it.