:: Life Of Dave ::

Education, a rambling entry

It's an interesting time to be academy-adjacent. So many small schools are closing, and larger schools are re-designing their programs to make their students 'more employable'.

A person who does work on this topic has been keeping a running overview of the situtation (here's his Summer 2024 update), and he references this story in the Chronicle of Higher Ed when noting that the liberal arts are taking a major hit.

I note a particular paragraph in the Chronicle story: "'We cannot and should not be all things to all people,' Charles L. Welch, president of the American Association of State Colleges and Universities, said, repeating a common refrain of higher ed’s era of contraction." When we moved to Arkansas I considered a PhD in Economics, but there are no programs in Central Arkansas, so I decided against it. These decisions to close programs are directly impacting what people study (not necessarily the other way around). Combined with the variety of headwinds facing K-12 programs, we will soon see a dramatic shift in graduates and their degrees. Given the world around us it seems an interesting time to decide we don't need people to study History, for example.

For a time I worked at the University of Arkansas Pulaski Tech, as an adjunct Economics instructor. I was struck by the makeup of the student body, which was in large part African-American and female. My guess is that this is the type of school that will be directed to offer only 'useful' programs, and leave the humanities to the flagship (5% African-American enrollment, according to Data USA). Rich white kids can 'do what they love' but poor black kids need a 'useful' degree? I suspect that's an oversimplification, and certainly liberal arts schools don't generally serve underpriviliged groups, but I do think there's a structural problem.

The Christian Broadcasting Network (or CBN, as they now seem to call themselves) had a story on this topic, and it was interesting to see them echoing other stories for the most part, rather than calling them cesspools of satan or whatever, which is what I had expected from the God's Not Dead crowd.

There's no doubt there are real challenges - the US simply has fewer people going to college than in the past, because there are literally fewer people. The Washington Times notes that Covid stimulus money papered over the problem, but now that money is gone and the problem remains.

Both of the above stories reference the market forces - higher prices, lower enrollment. Also a change in what people believe education is - the Times article quotes Michael Warder saying "A good number of young people believe software, technology and AI are the future, and there are opportunities to learn online or on the job at tech companies."

This, I think, gets at the heart of the matter. There's a fundamental shift in what people call education in the United States. I feel I need to specify that because these problems are, for the most part, America's problems, not anywhere else. And I'm not sure I know why that is.

Public colleges cannot go bankrupt - they might be allowed to, but it can't happen involuntarily unless the nation that funds them goes bankrupt. Choices are made by politicians, or by the public. So why aren't we seeing this other places? It must be that there's a difference in what people other places believe constitutes an education.

We're seeing a bit of it in the UK, and I think that's a bit of a giveaway - prices have been allowed to rise, and now that people have to pay for education they are asking 'how does this debt benefit me?' Market forces driving education, powered by individual consumers making individual decisions.

But it seems like this ignores the benefits society gains from having an educated populace.

I hunted around a bit and found this article by Hermannsson et al. from 2017 titled "The external benefits of higher education" which appeared in the journal Regional Studies. They note that "[i]t is pertinent to explore the external impacts of HE as, despite significant evidence, these impacts are not widely acknowledged in the policy process." A nearby paragraph is worth quoting more or less in full:

"Why are external impacts overlooked in policy design? One possibility is the relative underdevelopment of the evidence base. A second is that due to their microeconomic nature, perhaps they do not command attention in a policy environment accustomed to articulating impact in terms of macroeconomic aggregates, such as GDP and employment. Some of the evidence drawn on in this paper is itself controversial, reflecting the difficulties that beset attempts to measure accurately the external returns to education, and the comparatively limited body of research that has been devoted to this to date, compared to research on the private market returns to education. Part of the motivation for this work is to identify more clearly the gaps in our knowledge of the external impacts of HE."

Basically suggesting public policy seems to be ignoring the public benefit of education because nobody is studying the public benefit of education. Which, if we continue to prioritize only individual returns to education, nobody ever will.